# Give to Claude: Review the Multica MVP loop

You are Claude Code reviewing whether the Multica MVP setup worked.

Your job is to inspect the parent issue, child tickets, specialist handbacks, artifacts, and final Chief of Staff response. Return a clear pass/fail review with fixes.

## Safety

- Do not publish, deploy, send, spend, or edit production systems.
- Do not mark the workflow successful if evidence is missing.
- Do not hide blockers. A clear blocker is better than a fake pass.

## Step 1 — Inspect the parent issue

Find the parent issue created for the first SEO/site-growth request.

Check:

- assigned to Chief of Staff
- clear outcome
- child tickets named or linked
- status is understandable
- final handback exists or blocker is visible

## Step 2 — Inspect child tickets

Look for relevant child tickets, usually:

- SEO Consultant audit ticket
- Researcher ticket if extra evidence/context was needed
- Blog Writer ticket only if content work was justified

For each child ticket, check:

- owner is correct
- brief is clear
- inputs are named
- output is specified
- evidence labels are used
- approval constraints are present

## Step 3 — Inspect artifacts

Check whether substantial outputs are readable.

Expected:

- audit/report artifacts are readable HTML where useful
- blog/content drafts have approval previews if created
- artifacts are labelled draft/internal/not published
- claims are labelled confirmed/inferred/assumption/gap

## Step 4 — Decide status

Return exactly one:

- `Pass — MVP loop works`
- `Revise — setup or specialist work needs fixes`
- `Hold — blocked by access/setup/runtime issue`
- `Approval needed — human decision required before next action`

## Final review format

```md
## Status
Pass / Revise / Hold / Approval needed

## What worked
- ...

## What failed or was missing
- ...

## Evidence checked
- Parent issue: ...
- Child tickets: ...
- Artifacts: ...

## Fixes needed
- Owner: action

## Human approval needed
Exact decision, if any.
```

## Done when

- The human can tell whether the MVP loop actually worked.
- Any missing setup is turned into a specific next action.
- No success is invented.